A Review of Chapter 4:

Testimonials and Case Study Evidence

 

 

 

 

 

In the previous chapter, we reviewed the type of evidence used to support a theory and the ways it may be considered true.

 

·        Evidence from case studies and testimonials can be very useful at early stages of a psychological investigation

  •   However, case study information is useful only as a starting point as to what needs further investigation

 

 

 

 

·        In the later stages, they become useless because of:

 

 

 

 

1.     The Placebo Effect:  individuals reporting on the effectiveness of treatment, no matter what type of treatment was given or how effective it really was

2.   The Vividness Effect:  individuals reporting evidence that is specifically more vivid and therefore relying on this as evidence to a certain claim

 

 

 

  • Amazing Randi exposed the fraud of “psychic abilities”

 

 

Up Next…Chapter 5:

Correlation and Causation

 

 

 

 

 

·        In the previous chapter, we looked at the precautions when considering case study evidence and testimonials

 

 

·        In Chapter 5, we will look at another area that needs to be considered with caution:  Correlation and Causation

 

 

·        Here we discuss the presence of a correlation and how it does not automatically imply causation

 

 

Home